
Hello Andrew, You rail against Telstra, but where I am, there is zero choice. For mobile coverage, there are a few Telstra black spots where Optus has coverage, but far more of the reverse. I am cursing Telstra as there is ADSL either side of me, by something like four kilometers at the closest. My copper pair is about 1,000 meters to the base of a mobile phone tower, where there is ISDN equipment, but not ADSL. It used to be a very poor quality 11 plus kilometers to the nearest exchange, but now straight to fiber at the base of the mobile phone tower. Add to that that NBNCo is not due to pass here for quite some time, and that my mobile looses signal every now and then, sometimes when dry, not just wet foliage. When NBNCo take over the copper network, Telstra/Big Pond will no longer do dial up, and I will be forced to go 3G (that is the best the tower will support) on Big Pond. At least that way over contract gigabytes will be speed shaped, rather than an extra ten dollars for each over plan gigabyte that is the Telstra plan. Think about what it will take to get a DVD .ISO, currently not possible on my dial up. I am fortunate that I can visit a local friend with ADSL now and then for some updates and .ISO images. Think about what it would be like trying to cope with the Windows Updates pushed out without warning. I do not think much of Telstra, but that the other majors are even worse. Taking an on topic point, have you ever heard of being able to activate a USB modem under Linux? I gather many, even most, can be used, after activation, but the activation requires Windows, with a vague nod to Apple. I have even seen trouble, quite a few years back, with a Windows Netbook, one of the early ones that was also available with Linux. It belonged to a German national who brought it with him, and he had enormous trouble getting activation of anything. He even grabbed an update or two on a USB stick, and still did not work. As to reading any replies, that depends on the status of Telstra's modem pool, whether they answer, and whether they will let me log in, then whether the networking is functional. I suspect that there may be a problem with resetting and being ready when a Windows user just drops the line rather than logging out. However I have had it cut me off well under the ten hours that any one session may run up to, the dropping the connection happening from their end. They appear to not be looking after in this last time window before dropping the service. Regards, Mark Trickett

Hi Mark, The best solution for mobile data services using USB modems (3G or 4G) is to have a device running DD-WRT or similar as your "modem/router" .. but with the USB stick providing the modem part. Then you are back to only needing a wired connection to the router and/or wireless using standard WiFi. If Telstra wasn't so hell bent on milking every consumer [of any type] for as much as they can and if they cared about keeping our network up to world standards without super premium pricing, well .. I might be able to support them. Whilst they continue to extort far too much for their product, they don't deserve ANY support and will remain the last bastion of hope for those unfortunate enough to actually need to rely upon them. A.

On 05/08/15 07:26, Andrew McGlashan wrote:
Hi Mark,
The best solution for mobile data services using USB modems (3G or 4G) is to have a device running DD-WRT or similar as your "modem/router" .. but with the USB stick providing the modem part. Then you are back to only needing a wired connection to the router and/or wireless using standard WiFi.
Another option is to use a Mikrotik with a USB 3G/4G dongle. But again the DD-WRT is probably going to be more preferred by the community due to it being GNU rather than a propitiatory fork of Linux ;). But both technically will work fine. Plus side with Mikrotik is that you can get shiny hardware for relatively cheap. Cheers, Fraser

Hello Andrew, On Wed, 2015-08-05 at 07:26 +1000, Andrew McGlashan wrote:
Hi Mark,
The best solution for mobile data services using USB modems (3G or 4G) is to have a device running DD-WRT or similar as your "modem/router" .. but with the USB stick providing the modem part. Then you are back to only needing a wired connection to the router and/or wireless using standard WiFi.
Interesting, did not know that such devices had a USB port. Still a question on activation, whether possible under Linux, or whether still requires a Windows PC, optionally a Mac as an alternative. Were the activation to be done by a Perl script, with Perl being provided for Windows, then would be possible on almost any computer.
If Telstra wasn't so hell bent on milking every consumer [of any type] for as much as they can and if they cared about keeping our network up to world standards without super premium pricing, well .. I might be able to support them. Whilst they continue to extort far too much for their product, they don't deserve ANY support and will remain the last bastion of hope for those unfortunate enough to actually need to rely upon them.
Telstra are not good, but the rest are the same. As to network maintenance, investment and the like, Jackboot Johnny was hell bent on privatisation. As a Government monopoly, it was suboptimal, privatised and with competition, it has gone a long way backwards, lining executive pockets along the way. Regards, Mark Trickett

Hello Mark, On 5/08/2015 8:18 PM, Mark Trickett wrote:
On Wed, 2015-08-05 at 07:26 +1000, Andrew McGlashan wrote:
The best solution for mobile data services using USB modems (3G or 4G) is to have a device running DD-WRT or similar as your "modem/router" .. but with the USB stick providing the modem part. Then you are back to only needing a wired connection to the router and/or wireless using standard WiFi.
Interesting, did not know that such devices had a USB port. Still a question on activation, whether possible under Linux, or whether still requires a Windows PC, optionally a Mac as an alternative. Were the activation to be done by a Perl script, with Perl being provided for Windows, then would be possible on almost any computer.
Actually this is what I use in the car with a Netgear WNDR3700V1 unit. http://www.ofmodemsandmen.com/downloads.html FunnelWeb was my choice. (ROOTer, it's actually based on OpenWRT -- it works for me) Hardware options (both routers and modems) are listed on the site too, so best to find something that is known to work. http://www.ofmodemsandmen.com/supported.html I had no activation issues to consider, can't remember if the above link talks about alternative activation options; but I'm sure that I've read something somewhere... Cheers A.
participants (3)
-
Andrew McGlashan
-
Fraser McGlinn
-
Mark Trickett